A long-running internet conspiracy theory has resurfaced, linking Academy Award winner Anne Hathaway and her husband, Adam Shulman, to the world’s most famous playwright. The theory highlights the fact that William Shakespeare was married to a woman also named Anne Hathaway in 1582. Fans have flooded platforms like X and TikTok with side-by-side comparisons of Shulman and historical portraits of Shakespeare, claiming the physical resemblance is undeniable.

The romantic lore suggests that Shakespeare made a promise to make his wife famous in her next life, a sentiment fans believe has come true for the modern-day star of The Idea of You. Shulman, who married the actress in September 2012, shares similar facial features and deep-set eyes with the Bard. While the theory has circulated since at least 2018, it continues to gain traction every few months as new users discover the historical coincidence.

Anne Hathaway
Anne Hathaway — Photo: Harald Krichel / CC BY-SA 3.0 via Wikimedia Commons

Hathaway herself has acknowledged the whimsical connection that has captivated the public for years. During an appearance on The View in 2024, the actress was asked about the "internet's favorite conspiracy." Hathaway didn't shy away from the topic, telling the hosts, "It’s really cute," while discussing the poetic nature of the coincidence. Though she remains grounded in reality, she noted that the theory is one of the more charming rumors she has encountered during her career.